Aside from the fact that my pup didn't like these (we were test tasting), majority of the package contained large 1-inch square blobs. It was like the cutting machine took the day off. I won't purchase again because she doesn't like them AND because these couldn't be fed as treats, or fed as anything really.

Large pieces of liver. Not crumbles. Packaged and shipped well.

My dog just loves these treats.They are pretty big pieces for my 7 lb Maltese but I just cut them in half and they last at least 3 to 4 months on the 20 oz size barrel. PetGuys always delivers fast too! I can always depend on great prices and fast delivery plus courteous treatment if I have questions or need assistance. They return my call promptly as well. Great company to work with!

Packaging damaged container.

Our little lady loves these, very satisfied with these.

I have used these treats for years and every dog and cat I've had the pleasure to live with loves them. Never without some around.

these beef liver treats are the most reliable treat, as I have never met a dog who didn't like them, My dog Rocky who is very fussy about food, goes GAGA over these, absolutely the greatest dog treat.

My pup loves this stuff so much, have to get the large size! Best price for me was at PetGuys!

I have been ordering these now for years from PetGuys. My Vet recommended these for the dog when she was a baby and my dog has been hooked ever since. Problem is for the last few years, and more importantly the last 4 to 5 shipments, I notice that I am ordering these more frequently and there is a TON of fill in between all of the treats. By fill, I mean the crumbs and scraps that normally settle to the bottom are right beneath the first layer and the container is barely 3/4 full as it is. Best By: 3/20/17 and LOT 5079 for the items from my last order. Disappointed the standards are being set lower, and the consumer is getting more scraps than product.

Great price and quick shipping!

I've purchased this item many times. My dog and the cats both LOVE these. they last forever, so it is good to buy a large tub. No concern about it lodging in the intestinal tract, like rawhide does in some animals.

Its OK

Great price, fast delivery....our dogs favorite.

I have purchased this item many times. I find mainly full size pieces along with some smaller pieces. The bottom usually has some powder that I find useful as a sprinkle for their regular food. This is an outstanding product. It's a clean, wholesome treat that is a favorite in my kennel.

This is a necessity for dog owners. It makes a great training tool. It's a high value treat in "dogland". They love this treat more than anything else. It's useful in a variety of ways. It can easily be crushed into a powder. No additives. Love this product and this company. Best price anywhere! Customer service is tops!

I have been purchasing this product from PETGUYS for many years and have always had the best price and service.

My dogs go absolutely crazy over these treats. Every morning they ask for them. I wouldn't dare go a day without having these in our house. It makes them so happy. And they are healthy!

After several hit and miss attempts, I took my trainer's recommendation and bought the freeze dried beef liver treats to help train my dogs. Excellent choice and great results. After trying a no treat method and even a choke collar method of training, the use of these treats has shown me a more positive way to train resulting in an obedient, yet still happy dog. Great price too. Thanks.

I chose freeze-dried beef liver because my finnicky dog responded well to it in a rehab session, refusing other training treats. Beef liver doesn't get as powdery as freeze-dried chicken, so there is less waste. This product does come in small "cubes" (not all the same size and shape) suitable for training, but they can be cut down smaller for numerous repetitions of a training exercise (and to conserve product).

"Gimborn Company" many 'THINK' they're being 'clever' when they package their "Liver Treats" - but they MUST have actual packagers (or programed machines) who sprinkle ONLY about ONE INCH on VERY TOP of the container with VERY LARGE, PERFECTLY shaped Treats - but when you dig down ONLY about ONE INCH into the container - you find THE REST of the ENTIRE CONTAINER has NOTHING BUT small, uneven, broken up CHIPS of treats - NOTHING like the treats that are ON THE TOP!! Does the "Gimborn Company" REALLY think they can "FOOL" their customer like this?!? It is a VERY CHEAP and LOUSY way to treat their customers - who are NOT FOOLED by this DECEIVING PACKAGING!!!!

fast, efficient, worry free

I have been using Gimborn's Freeze Dried Liver Treats for both of my Mi-Kis since they were puppies. My dogs are -13# so I use utility scissors to cut the beef chunks into smaller bites. The chicken livers break easily into smaller chunks. Both of my dogs and my daughter's Shitzu love these all beef, all chicken liver treats, and I feel they are healthy for them without a lot of unusual additives.

My dogs are very picky and these treats are like candy to them. They could eat a whole bucket in a day if I would let them. Perfect treat-small and no mess at all.

They come in small pieces so you can give them exactly the amount they need for their size. They love them

Long time customer & always pleased with the products & prices offered by the PetGuys!